What's new

Show Off Signature Collection Thread

  • Thread starter Orange Mushroom
  • Start date
  • Views 311
O

Orange Mushroom

Enthusiast
Messages
879
Reaction score
184
Some signatures I made, any feedback is appreciated.

2mi29uc.png

zn687m.png

dd24as.png

kd4o5t.png

I also have some userbars and more old signatures, but can't find them for some reason..
 
H

Holo

I am Holo, and Holo is all that I am
Retired
Messages
4,661
Reaction score
3,424
Not really feeling the center focal. Top one is nice. The rest are ok. I would work on the text. Second sig is a little monotone. Black and white sigs can be good but they have to be done right. Not bad. 1st one is the best one imo.
 
O

Orange Mushroom

Enthusiast
Messages
879
Reaction score
184
Not really feeling the center focal. Top one is nice. The rest are ok. I would work on the text. Second sig is a little monotone. Black and white sigs can be good but they have to be done right. Not bad. 1st one is the best one imo.


Yes, I was already aware of the second one, thought the same to be honest.
I'm already working on improving my text, thanks for the feedback though.
 
H

Holo

I am Holo, and Holo is all that I am
Retired
Messages
4,661
Reaction score
3,424
Yes, I was already aware of the second one, thought the same to be honest.
I'm already working on improving my text, thanks for the feedback though.


Don't worry, I'm in the same boat with you when it comes to text.
 
L

-Le Me-

Self-Certified Polymath
Messages
1,335
Reaction score
500
Tbh I kind of prefer the second one over the first one because in the first one, it's quite hard to recognize what's actually going on. It's a bit too messy for me, so I'd suggest you to work on your focal and make the render 'stand out'. The second one is decent apart from being oversharpened, but you should work on your text and text placement. Also, the last one has an interesting style.
 
O

Orange Mushroom

Enthusiast
Messages
879
Reaction score
184
Took me some time to find my old thread back, anyway here's another try at a signature:
17y78y.png


Feedback is appreciated!
 
H

Holo

I am Holo, and Holo is all that I am
Retired
Messages
4,661
Reaction score
3,424
Took me some time to find my old thread back, anyway here's another try at a signature:
17y78y.png


Feedback is appreciated!


Depth, lighting, and blending could use quite a bit of work. Also, I don't really see the render. I know it's somewhere in the middle-left area but I don't know what the render looks like.

I would explain the parts that seem "wrong" but I don't feel like typing a paragraph. On top of that, most people don't really want to read a long wall of text anyways.

Font placement is nice, although I can barely see what it says.

I like the composition however. Just work on those top 3 and you will be good to go. Keep it up brother.
 
H

HangtimePro

Permanently Plugged In
Messages
3,996
Reaction score
1,297
Some signatures I made, any feedback is appreciated.

2mi29uc.png

zn687m.png

dd24as.png

kd4o5t.png

I also have some userbars and more old signatures, but can't find them for some reason..

I really like the top one, it has the best balance from out of all the images. :smile:
 
Top Bottom