What's new

Discussion Petition to remove Xbox One Reputation System

  • Thread starter dolphinkid01
  • Start date
  • Views 2,560
K

Kakashi

OG
A Milli Mythical Veteran CotM
Messages
6,035
Reaction score
3,088
Points
1,395
It's a huge problem in MCC now as well. Players in the higher ranks are having problems with kids abusing the system due to a fair loss.
I got to a 33 on my new account and can't play anymore because I'm red. So fun.
Whats the big deal about the reputation bar. No one actually gives a **** about that. hahah
if your reputation is red you can't even find a game on cod advanced warfare, and it has the most players all the time, same with Fifa.
 
Saturday Night

Saturday Night

Getting There
Messages
1,416
Reaction score
412
Points
180
I don't think it needs removed, just modified greatly.

I have friends who play Halo(they are really good, actually, insanely good). Some of them get avoided so much that it'll lock them out of matchmaking due to this Rep system.

Even looking at what's been filed on me, I have 3 reports for cheating(which I don't do) and even had one on my gamertag(which isn't offensive or break ToS, like not even close).

People will click anything to avoid someone, which in the end will hurt usually good players with this system.

But from what I understand is, is that this new UI has a few improvements with the Rep system, so we'll see.
 
kek

kek

Enthusiast
Messages
117
Reaction score
13
Points
70
I doubt a petition would actually have any role in having the reputation system removed. Although it's stupid as f*** and abused more than my penis Microsoft really doesn't care. Also anybody that is on the red end of the Reputation System have you tried contacting support?
 
D

dolphinkid01

Newbie
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
Points
45
Pyroman

Pyroman

No
VIP
Retired
Messages
5,980
Reaction score
5,564
Points
2,420
Just make a bunch of xbox accounts with the free one month and report your main for being good or whatever its called.
 
Tyler

Tyler

Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips &
Grammar Nazi Hardened Veteran Forum Addict
Messages
8,078
Reaction score
2,092
Points
670
I swear, everyone is innocent on Xbox LIVE...
 
Spyro

Spyro

4/18/10
VIP
Stickied Mythical Veteran End of the Year 2012
Messages
18,206
Reaction score
12,643
Points
2,580
I got to a 33 on my new account and can't play anymore because I'm red. So fun.

if your reputation is red you can't even find a game on cod advanced warfare, and it has the most players all the time, same with Fifa.
Same with MCC and Gears. 
I swear, everyone is innocent on Xbox LIVE...
You're the most innocent right
 
Tyler

Tyler

Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips &
Grammar Nazi Hardened Veteran Forum Addict
Messages
8,078
Reaction score
2,092
Points
670
You're the most innocent right

Well, I remain with good rep and don't get myself suspended.

So yeah, I'd say I'm doing well for myself. But I also own up when I actually get suspended or something. I don't cry about how I did nothing wrong.
 
D

dolphinkid01

Newbie
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
Points
45
Well, I remain with good rep and don't get myself suspended.

So yeah, I'd say I'm doing well for myself. But I also own up when I actually get suspended or something. I don't cry about how I did nothing wrong.
Who are you to say you know if someone's innocent on Xbox or not? Tons of people are having this problem, even some big Gears of War players.
 
Tyler

Tyler

Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips &
Grammar Nazi Hardened Veteran Forum Addict
Messages
8,078
Reaction score
2,092
Points
670
Who are you to say you know if someone's innocent on Xbox or not? Tons of people are having this problem, even some big Gears of War players.
Maybe some are...but with the track record if users on Xbox LIVE, it's a little hard to believe anyone.
 
K

Kakashi

OG
A Milli Mythical Veteran CotM
Messages
6,035
Reaction score
3,088
Points
1,395
Maybe some are...but with the track record if users on Xbox LIVE, it's a little hard to believe anyone.
By some, I hope you mean damn near everybody. This system is stupid. If I don't like somebody because they beat me LEGITIMATELY then I can report them for cheating or their gamertag for being offensive and then they can't play xbox anymore. Makes sense, seems legit.
 
Tyler

Tyler

Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips & Bacon Strips &
Grammar Nazi Hardened Veteran Forum Addict
Messages
8,078
Reaction score
2,092
Points
670
By some, I hope you mean damn near everybody. This system is stupid. If I don't like somebody because they beat me LEGITIMATELY then I can report them for cheating or their gamertag for being offensive and then they can't play xbox anymore. Makes sense, seems legit.
Yes. Some.

Not everyone is like that. Not everyone runs into crap like this.

So yes. Some.
 
K

Kakashi

OG
A Milli Mythical Veteran CotM
Messages
6,035
Reaction score
3,088
Points
1,395
Yes. Some.

Not everyone is like that. Not everyone runs into crap like this.

So yes. Some.
Literally all of my friends -1 person has had orange or red rep within the last month. This problem is increasing big time and it is getting out of hand. You shouldn't be able to take away somebody's right to play a game they purchased with their own money because you got butthurt that you lost or don't like them. I paid money for all of my games out of my own money, so that I can play them with my friends online. Can't do that now.
 
Neokilla

Neokilla

Life is what you make it.
Programmer Legendary Veteran Platinum Record
Messages
3,028
Reaction score
1,338
Points
1,300
Literally all of my friends -1 person has had orange or red rep within the last month. This problem is increasing big time and it is getting out of hand. You shouldn't be able to take away somebody's right to play a game they purchased with their own money because you got butthurt that you lost or don't like them. I paid money for all of my games out of my own money, so that I can play them with my friends online. Can't do that now.
I agree it is stupid and they have already said they're working on this. But only 1 out of my 55 friends is below green bar.
 
Extinct

Extinct

絶滅
Super Moderators
Content Team
Bug Finder Frame In Gold Glitcher
Messages
7,820
Solutions
5
Reaction score
4,278
Points
2,340
I wouldn't really say it needs to go but maybe it could be re worked out.
 
Durva

Durva

Professional Scrub
Experienced Veteran Grizzled Veteran Seasoned Veteran
Messages
1,645
Reaction score
568
Points
365
Only one person on my friends list has been in the constant orange/red stage. However that is likely due to my brother being a complete idiot and trash talking anyone that doesn't agree with him. Not to mention he does a lot of custom games on Cod/Halo and reports anyone for not playing exactly how he tells them :/
 
K

Kakashi

OG
A Milli Mythical Veteran CotM
Messages
6,035
Reaction score
3,088
Points
1,395
I agree it is stupid and they have already said they're working on this. But only 1 out of my 55 friends is below green bar.
I have a small friends list of people I play with weekly, like 15 people
 
Top Bottom
Login
Register